This paper was presented in collaboration with Lauren Villarama of UP-D CSSP at the 31st (UGAT) Ugnayang Pang-Aghamtao / Anthropological Association of the Philippines Annual Conference
"The (Re)Making of Cities and its Consequences."
22-24 October 2009
Xavier University, Cagayan de Oro City
The Neo-Urban Plan
The Neo-Urban Plan is an ongoing online project initiated by multimedia artist Mark Salvatus. Through the blog Neo-Urban Planner, he called for ideas on how to ‘improve’ or ‘change’ cities. Salvatus aimed to make the project as the bridging tool for an interactive dialogue between the city and the people who live in it. Salvatus envisioned the project to be a platform to present creative change coming from the people/”city dwellers” themselves, and that the ideas they come up with would eventually be presented to city administrators, local officials, and yes, the MMDA. The project did not specify any particular city or urban area—participants were free to choose the locale of their suggestions. The project sparked interest from different sectors—plans were received from individuals and organizations of different backgrounds, and prompting these “neo-urban planners” to present their ideas amid an audience.
To jumpstart the project, Mark Salvatus posted a ‘sample plan’: putting hanging gardens on footbridges. He also suggested the use of boats for Manila’s CaMaNaVa area, referring to the cities of Caloocan, Malabon, Navotas, and Valenzuela. These areas experience perennial flooding even when there are no heavy rains, due to its location by bay. Salvatus toyed with the idea to ‘convert’ parts of CaMaNaVa into floating markets—much like that of Thailand. “I have been to the floating market and someone told me that it was a flood zone area. The residents made it sustainable by turning their flooded community into a market and a tourist spot,” Salvatus wrote in the Neo-Urban Planner blog. His urban plan then was to make the most out of a problem—turning this into a solution. Of course, it would be better if those living in those areas would come up with this idea on their own.
Here are just a few of the submissions for the Neo-Urban Plan so far:
Setting the mood with photography. The project launch opened with a slideshow presentation of images taken around Manila by photo enthusiast Gem Urdaneta. The presentation became a guessing/memory game of sorts as the audience tried to identify what the shots were of and where these were taken. It “set the mood” for an urban-centric discussion and made the audience “re-view” the city and its structures that are often taken for granted when one sees it on a daily basis.
Greening the city. Educator Diego Maranan laid out a detailed plan:
1) Have 80% of all exposed cement, concrete, or metal in the city covered in a creeping plant of some sort, like ivy
2) Find or bioengineer great, big, tall, sturdy, flexible trees that can withstand typhoons and have massive canopies and blanket the city under interlocking canopies
3) Ban the use of concrete in certain areas or certain structures. Only volcanic ash, wood, bamboo, recycled plastic, rubber, brick, mud, straw, whatever is appropriate
4) Link all the equipment in Manila's gyms to a power-generating mechanism so that every time we go on the treadmill or lift weights, we generate electricity that is stored somewhere and is used to power... Street lights. Traffic lights. A mechanical art installation. Or if not all of Manila's gyms, then have a stationary bike/power-generation center.
5) Go to communities and ask people to model their ideal version of the city using children's clay.
Comfort for all. Art writer Clarissa Chikiamco suggested turning the for-males-only urinals into “real” public toilets in bus stops.
More than just child’s play. Interestingly, from the online project Salvatus also received an invitation to conduct a workshop at the Museo Pambata in Manila about mapping and clay city planning together with the Children’s Advocates Program. The workshop, titled “Clay City,” allowed the children residing in the Parola Compound in Tondo, Manila to be urban planners for a day (February 28, 2009). The workshop also supported Diego Maranan’s suggestion to ask people to model their ideal version of the city using children’s clay.
Aside from the submitted suggestions for the Neo-Urban Plan, the initiating artist invited individuals and groups who deal with the urban environment as their subject of interest to weekly presentations at the host gallery. The presentations ranged from art talks, visual art exhibitions, and film screenings. These presentations gave an insight to the urban culture that inspired the participants.
Graffiti artists presented a short audio-visual on why they paint the streets; a discussion on the skating culture of Manila was also conducted; and even the emerging alternative sport parkour was given its time in the NUP limelight. Young contemporary conceptual artists created visual and audio representations/interpreta
The presentations, though not suggestions for change as called for by the NUP, nonetheless showed the urbanscape and lifestyle as experienced and expressed by the graffiti artists, skaters, parkours, and conceptual artists who participated in the project. The sharing of ideas and thoughts about the city created for them a placeworld—a shared understanding of the city, of what the city is for them—that is worth exploring.
Implications of the NUP Project
At this point it is important to note that, with the exception of the children of Parola Compund, most of the suggestions and presentations were by people from Salvatus’ own network of young artists and urban culture ‘colleagues’. Nonetheless, to derive their sense of aesthetics, it is necessary to ask “why” in inquiring the reason behind the suggestions.
[The next ‘phase’ of the project (and the ongoing study) should then be a more in-depth analysis of the submitted suggestions and presentations. How did they arrive at these ideas?]
The NUP, in creating a shared understanding of urban space as experienced by the participants, created a placeworld with a common view of urban culture—hip, expressive, leaning on the visual, and questioning what is functional and aesthetic. In submitting their suggestions and presentations, the participants of the NUP allowed us to look at their own aesthetics and sense of what is appropriate for a place, what their city should have.
Looking back at the suggestions cited here, we can give a short analysis of what constitutes the placeworld of the participants and their sense of aesthetics as they exercised it: for example, in Diego Maranan’s suggestion, exposed cement, concrete, or metal in the city should be covered in a creeping plant, like ivy. This could mean that “bare” exposed cement is aesthetically ‘lacking’ or unappealing, and also, considering the rest of his suggestion, he would like to have a ‘green’ city with its own power-generating capacities. In turn, what do his suggestions imply about the city? We must also note that he was the one who suggested asking people to model their ideal version of the city. This certainly is a participatory activity that can be part of future urban planning. On another aspect, Clarissa Chikiamco’s suggestion to create public toilets for males and females is an implication of the desire to have an equal comfort zone for all, not just for the males who need to pass water every now and then. The suggestion looks more aesthetically appealing too (as for the “olfactory aesthetics” however, we’ll just have to see).
The initiating artist’s own suggestion, to use boats for flood-prone areas, turning these into livelihood must-haves not only used for fishing but also for trade, suggests a growing consciousness of climate change and a sense of necessity for climate change adaptation, to be proactive instead of reactive.
Taking off from the sustainable suggestions, the Neo-Urban Plan also hosted a mini-exhibit of the winners of the YP Design Challenge, a competition that “seeks to encourage young design professionals to apply their creative abilities and design skills to projects addressing real community needs.” The winning designs, according to Salvatus, can be models for housing institutions and providers like the National Housing Authority (NHA) and the Gawad Kalinga. The suggestion was for these institutions to consider the type of designs lauded in the competition—low-cost and environment-friendly housing but with a very high aesthetic value—in the houses they build.
The Neo-Urban Plan, as an exercise in ethnoaesthetics, elicited people’s vision of a city and the changes that they would like to see made to improve their surroundings and the way they live. It also opened our eyes to certain aspects of the process of urban planning that may have been lacking—in particular, the engagement of those who live in the city. Through the NUP, previously disempowered individuals and groups were given a semblance of power to control how cities look, a form of artistic license to participate in the production of designed spaces. From passive viewers of the changes going on in the city (including the pink-and-bluing), the participants became proactive urban planners, albeit only visually, online, or through projects and activities such as the design competition and clay city building. As art writer Lisa Ito put it, the Neo-Urban Plan “directs improvement and creativity towards community-centric advancement rather than expanding state-sponsored aberrations.”
‘Inward’ thoughts
One thing I learned by doing community development work is that when people have a sense of ownership, they tend to protect or take care of what is owned and not alien structures. When one sees more of the self in programs, projects, and structures, one becomes more responsible, and there is a conscious effort to build or work toward the advancement of these programs and, in the context of this study, structures. Thus, a strategy used by local governments is to say “alagaan ang lungsod—atin ito,” to instill a sense of community and to elicit cooperation. Note that most vandals are on walls and structures marked “government property.”
The Neo-Urban Plan is an example of a ground-up instead of a top-down plan for a city, to use terms commonly used in community development. This gives ‘urban development’ a positive meaning to people, instead of connoting that ‘development’ simply means more sidewalk clearing operations, more (not-so-people-friendly) footbridges, and more concrete.
Recommendations and Challenges
What’s next for the project?
• The project has had a good start in providing an avenue for the expression of ethnoaesthetics. The continuation of the project is crucial in maintaining a dialogue about how people experience their placeworlds and in eliciting ideas for development.
• The ideas and suggestions submitted for the NUP would remain ‘in the air’ unless these are realized/put to action/concretized with the cooperation and participation of the governing bodies concerned, in particular, local city planners and yes, the MMDA.
• It is also recommended that more participatory activities in urban planning are conducted, not only in Metro Manila, but in other areas as well. Local governments and city planners together with the communities may collaborate and conduct their own ‘versions’ of the project, with participatory aesthetics as the main idea behind the planning. The resulting project must enable communities to express their own visions of and ambitions for public space—why waste funds on structures that have no meaning for a people?
• Taking off from the earlier suggestions, it would be best to include plans for disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation (as is appropriate per area) in future ideas.
What’s next for anthropology?
The challenge for Philippine anthropology now is to use our knowledge of ethnoaesthetics and the significance of placeworlds in pursuing studies related to space (conflicting spaces, embodied spaces, etc.), urban aesthetics, and urban planning and be able to apply these to wherever these are appropriate and necessary.
__________________________
The Children's Advocacy Program or CAP is an alternative educational program that aims to help children understand and appreciate their roles in their families, schools, communities, and in society. It uses the child-to-child approach wherein children advocates serve as mentors who help inspire other disadvantaged Filipino children through outreach activities in schools and communities. Children advocates are chosen from various street children centers and disadvantaged communities and are exposed to workshops, field trips and film showings to enhance their awareness on identity, nation-building, rights and values formation. CAP is a venue for children to learn how to formulate ideas and speak their minds on issues affecting them. [http://www.museopambata.or
______________________
WEDNESDAYS i'm-n-love OPEN PLATFORM RESIDENCY (WOP) is an experimental and creative laboratory for new artistic explorations in contemporary visual arts, performance, and new media. Six local artists/curators/researche
References
Young, Jane M. (1998). Ethnoaesthetics. in Folklore: An Encyclopedia of Beliefs, Customs, Tales, Music and Art (Hardcover). Edited by Thomas A. Green. Published by ABC-CLIO.
Gordon, Eric & Gene Koo. (2008). Placeworlds: Using Virtual Worlds to Foster Civic Engagement. in
Space and Culture vol. 11 no. 3, August 2008 204-221. Sage Publications.
Ito, Lisa. (2009). Art and its Public/s | Broad topic: Art of/degrees of Engagement . Pananaw 7.
http://www.greenpapayaartp
http://papayapost.blogspot
http://neourbanplanner.blo
http://ypdesignchallenge.t
http://www.museopambata.or
http://wednesdaysmnlove.bl
No comments:
Post a Comment